Denominational Doctrine on Damnation: The Developing Story of the Bible Fellowship Church

In January of 2022, a church petitioned its parent denomination to reexamine biblical teaching on hell, in part because some congregants had embraced annihilationism. As reported in the minutes of its 139th annual meeting, the Bible Fellowship Church (BFC) was asked by member Whitehall BFC “to form a study committee of five people to examine what Scripture teaches about the eternal destiny of the unregenerate, with careful attention to both its apologetic and shepherding use.”1“Whitehall BFC Petition to BFC Conference,” One Hundred Thirty-nineth Annual Meeting of the Bible Fellowship Church Conference 2022, rev. ed., 137. The stated reason behind the petition:

Whitehall Church has been ministering to some who have serious doubts regarding the eternal conscious torment of the unregenerate; some of whom have abandoned the Faith in large measure due to this historic doctrine of the Church, and others who (remaining devoted to Christ and His Word) have moved away from the eternal conscious torment position and to an annihilation position . . .

Two years later, BFC published its “Report of the Study Committee on Eternal Conscious Torment” on pages 97–111 of its 141st Conference Report Book. It concludes, “passages throughout Scripture indicate that an annihilationist position doesn’t, in a sense, fit the crime,” and “we believe that the Bible teaches that those whose names are not written in the book of life will experience an eternal conscious torment.”2“Report of the Study Committee on Eternal Conscious Torment,” Bible Fellowship Church 141st Conference Report Book, 109–110. Unfortunately, the provided analysis, on which the committee based its conclusions, reflects a poorly informed and less-than-careful study of conditional immortality (or annihilationism) and the larger subject of biblical teaching about hell. Continue reading “Denominational Doctrine on Damnation: The Developing Story of the Bible Fellowship Church” →

 

References
↑1 “Whitehall BFC Petition to BFC Conference,” One Hundred Thirty-nineth Annual Meeting of the Bible Fellowship Church Conference 2022, rev. ed., 137.
↑2 “Report of the Study Committee on Eternal Conscious Torment,” Bible Fellowship Church 141st Conference Report Book, 109–110.